Online ordering powered by Seamless
23 E 51st Street (212) 371-7676
Minimum order of $8.00 is required for delivery
Delivery estimate is 25-40 min (more info)
Unfortunately, Toasties (51st) is not open at the delivery/pickup time that you selected. Please make sure that you've entered an address and try changing the time in the Order Information section to the right.
Seamless allows you to enjoy convenient online ordering from the best local restaurants. If you're ordering for the first time, start your order by entering your address to the right. Return users log in here.
Minimum order of $8.00 is required for delivery
Delivery estimate is 15 - 30 min (more info)
Print this menu
Served Monday-Friday until 10:59am.
Available after 11:00am.
Available after 11:00am. All Cheese & Veggy sandwiches are vegetarian.
no rye bread
Offering quality food at reasonable prices, Toasties provides a unique touch to your everyday cuisine. This gourmet sandwich and salad shop located in upper midtown west serves a potpourri of delectable delights, a cut above your average New York deli. With signature sandwiches that are created from a combination of ingredients that you will not find elsewhere, once you visit Toasties, you are sure to return for more.
Click here to view our corporate catering menu!
Horrible delivery service. Took two hours to get order when the confirmation said 15-30 minutes.
Posted 2 years ago by Hayley N.
horrible....i was given cajun chicken instead of grilled chicken and i cant eat anything spicy so there goes my lunch for today
Posted 2 years ago by Denise C.
ATTENTION TOASTIES - I hope you read these reviews. I love this restaurant and order from it multiple times a week. But what is with the delivery recently? In the past I only have to wait 15-20 minutes for delivery. Once my sandwich came in 10 minutes - literally. Lately delivery has taken 40+ minutes.
Are you down delivery people? Please hire more people because this is getting to be ridiculous.
I will still give you 5 stars but only in the hopes that you get it together and figure out how to fix the broken machine.
Posted 2 years ago by Winston R.
Toastie's staff is quick and the food is delicious and fresh. Sometimes ordering online diminishes the option to customize orders. Not the case here. Make this spot your regular choice for high quality meals on the go.
Posted 2 years ago by Trevor C.
good food, very conveniently located and very excited that they now have a juice bar!
Posted 2 years ago by Laura R.
I got the "Boss" from here. It was dank.
Posted 2 years ago by Carlos C.
Everyday I write specific instructions on how to prepare my order and everyday something is wrong with the order. I called and asked why and they said they were improvising. Why didn't they call and inform me? Seamless charges more for the order and TIP is always included and they cannot get the order correct !!!
Posted 2 years ago by Hector P.
Menu has option to order H&H bagel. When you select it gives you the ability to order bagel and toast. They take order as only giving you 1 item. Twice I got hosed by this and only got toast until I called. When I did call in, they were not helpful in fixing situation- will not be ordering from here again
Posted 2 years ago by Jeff C.
Literally the best Chicken Caesar wrap I've ever had.
Posted 2 years ago by Leo E.
only about a 10% chance of getting what you ordered within an hour.
Posted 2 years ago by Michael K.
Quick and easy! I work around the corner from here and it's the most convenient place ever. I usually order online and come pick up, and even though it gets super busy during lunch..I'm never waiting. Food taste great and the employees are kind.
Posted 2 years ago by kris y.
Toasties 51st Street (Catering) prepares wonderful foods with beautiful color using flowers and other accents to garnish dishes for a superb presentation. Their consistent service and professionalism is also hard to find especially when coordinating for numerous lunch meetings.
Posted 2 years ago by Khadija B.
They make great breakfast wraps and the delivery is quick but I also found a hair in my energy wrap. Hopefully it never happens again.
Posted 2 years ago by Melissa T.
some of the best sandwiches I've eaten in the area
Posted 2 years ago by Daniel H.
THE FOOD IS ALWAYS FRESH AND TASTES THE SAME EVERY TIME.
CLEAN AND REFRESHING ALWAYS!
Posted 2 years ago by Shameeza M.
Posted 3 years ago by franklyn d.
Turkey & pastrami sandwich was pretty average, dressing and cheese were missing despite special directions, which was disappointing.
Posted 3 years ago by James N.
I have had my food delivered and picked up from Toasties and they are always extremely prompt and friendly. Delivery usually is much faster than the estimated time, and this is one of the few places that will bring my food upstairs instead of asking me to come down to the lobby; perfect for days with back-to-back meetings. Love my breakfast veggie wrap and the Popeye, Alice, and Emily Waits sandwiches.
Posted 3 years ago by Emily O.
Sandwich was great until I bit into a piece of bone. Lost my appetite after that and threw away the rest of the sandwich. Disappointing.
Posted 3 years ago by Dean S.
Food is always fresh and delicious. You don't have to worry about them skimping on ingredients. In years of ordering from them, I don't recall having any mix ups, and they are usually able to deliver under the given time frame... what more can you ask for?
Posted 3 years ago by Dennis B.
This place is the worst. Delivery always takes well over an hour and food arrives cold. Don't waste your time.
Posted 4 years ago by Kyle M.
Everything is good, every time. The build a salads are huge and the sandiwiches are delicious.
Posted 4 years ago by Thomas B.
Love Toasties! I prefer ordering online because it takes a big chunk of my lunch hour to wait for my order to be made on location. Best sandwich is the Sargeant Sweet Pepper.
Posted 4 years ago by Lina R.
Their fruit bowl is really fresh and their large salads are huge! The hot sandwiches are also amazing on a whole wheat hero. Fastest delivery so far of all the restaurants I've tried on seamless.
Posted 4 years ago by Lindsey N.
Quick delivery. High quality ingredients and attention to detail
Posted 4 years ago by Peter W.
The steam table sandwiches alone are worth the hassle of living in New York some days.
Posted 4 years ago by Grahme D.
Good deli meat and fixings are very fresh; quick delivery. Loses one star for not having real turkey for the Thanksgiving Sandwich I wanted! I ended up getting the Caspar which was still very good.
Posted 4 years ago by Karen B.
Awesome food. Offers a wide variety of items. Soups, hot food, sandwiches, salads....doesn't matter what I'm in the mood for, it's all there. Deliveries can be backed up sometimes but food quality still stands. It's fresh and delicious.
Posted 5 years ago by Patricia A.
I order the same thing from here everyday for breakfast. Yet service and delivery is so inconsistent, with delivery times taking up to 2 hours. 2 HOURS for breakfast to be made and delivered a block over?! Not only that, orders get messed up after waiting so long. They've promised to fix the order or give credit back and unfortunately, never do. I usually end up go to my credit card to have the charges cancelled.
Posted 5 years ago by Stephanie W.
must be under new ownership, quality of food and service has fallen from grace.
Posted 5 years ago by Kaveh K.
had the chicken salad sandwich with bacon (birdie, i think it's called), and it was amazing!
Posted 5 years ago by Katelyn S.
Very consistent and well made sandies. Delivery is also very prompt for midtown.
Posted 5 years ago by Tom B.
Toasties is the best for breakfast delivery - fast, cheap and delicious. Lunch also offers a huge variety of options, from un-boring sandwiches to delicious hot foods. Can't go wrong with Toasties!
Posted 5 years ago by Megan B.
my new obsession! where else can you have a sandwich EXACTLY how you want it? and toasted to boot? I have re-imagined many classic sandwiches of my adolescents and college years using the extensive options at this super fast eatery! I love this place!
Posted 5 years ago by SARAH D.
Great meals for all!!! Excellent salad and great value
Posted 5 years ago by Lynne D.
WORST SERVICE EVER
MADE ME WAIT 30 minutes DOWNSTAIRS FOR A DELIVERY GUY THAT NEVER CAME AND HE KEPT ON CLAIMING TO BE IN THE LOBBY OF MY BUILDING.
HAPPENDED TWICE IN TWO WEEKS. WILL NEVER ORDER FROM THIS PLACE AGAIN.
Posted 5 years ago by Luk L.
Outstanding philly cheesesteak
Posted 6 years ago by Will O.
excellent food and fast delivery!
Posted 6 years ago by Caitlin M.
My sandwich was hot, fresh & tasty. The order arrived quickly & accurately.
Posted 6 years ago by Jennifer H.
very quick delivery!
Posted 6 years ago by robin p.
Clean, good food, and nice staff. They keep the soup pots covered unless they're serving you, AND, both the soup and salad fixings are kept behind glass so only the staff has access to it. Very sanitary.
Posted 6 years ago by Jennifer C.
AWESOME food, QUICK delivery.
Posted 6 years ago by Sudeep P.
Only select user reviews are published on Seamless. All user-submitted ratings contribute to Toasties (51st)'s overall Seamless rating, but we manually screen all reviews and only publish those that are relevant and helpful. Tips for getting your review published »
Above content provided by restaurant.
Order online from
Toasties (51st) by entering your address
below. Online ordering powered by Seamless.com.
Return users log
Click a menu item to add it to your order.
Back to top
Seamless North America, LLC. All Rights Reserved.
0808 234 7862
Seamless North America, LLC. All Rights Reserved.